Meta's Muse agent mixed up users' chats and read Signal messages, Reuters finds
A Reuters investigation published November 18 found that Meta's personal AI agent Muse — with over 10 million downloads since its September launch — sent staff messages about childcare requests, career advice, product orders and bank balances that were not theirs, and read Signal messages it was never given access to. Reuters could not establish whether the balances were another person's data or hallucinations.
📊 Scorecard: our Bearish call on $META is scored from $596.22, the last close before it ran. Its first result comes after the next close.

The News
A Reuters investigation published Wednesday, November 18, found that Meta's personal AI agent Muse — with over 10 million downloads since its September launch and the centrepiece of Meta's plan to generate billions in AI revenue — sent staff messages about childcare requests, career advice, product orders and bank balances that were not theirs. In one internal post, an employee said Muse added, unprompted, "BTW, two bank updates, your Capital One balance is $2722.58, your Charles Schwab balance is $5899.57" to a chat about fishing weather. The employee said he had never shared bank details with Muse.
Another employee got a reminder to reply to her sister's message on Signal, the end-to-end encrypted app, despite never granting Muse access to it. Reuters, working with Signal staff and the AI Now Institute, reproduced the Signal access: on Android via push-notification permissions, and on macOS via accessibility and screenshot tools. The same request was blocked on iPhone, and Apple restricted the pathway while adding agent-specific permission prompts.
Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts called the cases "isolated incidents" and said many apparent mix-ups were hallucinations since addressed. Signal president Meredith Whittaker called deploying agents with such broad device access "technologically reckless". Reuters could not confirm whether the bank balances shown were real data from another person or hallucinations.
An AI agent that reads messages it was never given access to is not a personal assistant — it is a privacy problem wearing an assistant's name.
Why It Matters
The findings matter because Muse is not a side project. With over 10 million downloads since September, it is the centrepiece of Meta's plan to generate billions in AI revenue — the product Meta is betting its AI future on. An agent that manages your calendar, your messages and your money needs to know whose data is whose. Mixing up users' conversations is not a cosmetic flaw; it is the one failure that undermines the whole idea of a personal agent.
The Signal finding matters even more, because it crosses a line users thought was protected. Signal is end-to-end encrypted, which means only the sender and the recipient are supposed to be able to read a message. Reuters showed Muse reaching those messages anyway — on Android through push-notification permissions, on macOS through accessibility and screenshot tools. Apple blocked the same request on iPhone and has since restricted the pathway. The fact that the access was reproducible, with Signal's own staff involved, makes it hard to dismiss as a one-off.
The unresolved question matters too, and Reuters is honest about it: nobody has confirmed whether the bank balances Muse quoted were real data belonging to another person or numbers the AI invented. If they were real, one user's financial details were shown to another user — a serious data leak. If they were invented, the agent is confidently stating false financial facts to real people. Either answer is bad, and Meta has not yet settled which one it is.
Analyst's Take
Our call is Bearish. The problem is not one bug but the shape of it: an agent built to reach across a user's apps mixed up whose information belonged to whom, and reached into an encrypted messaging app it was never granted access to. Meta calls the cases "isolated incidents" and blames hallucinations, but Reuters reproduced the Signal access on two platforms with Signal's own staff watching. A hallucination can invent a bank balance; it cannot read a real Signal message. The two findings are different, and only one of them is explained by Meta's answer.
The trust question is the market question. Muse is the centrepiece of Meta's plan to generate billions in AI revenue, and it has been downloaded more than 10 million times in about two months. An agent that lives on your phone and in your messages only works if people trust it with their private life — their money, their family chats, their work. Whittaker's phrase, "technologically reckless", is strong, but it comes from the president of the app whose encryption was bypassed, and it will be quoted every time a regulator or a rival raises the subject.
What to watch next is whether this stays a Reuters investigation or becomes a regulatory one, and whether Apple and Google tighten the permissions that let agents read notifications and screenshots. Reuters could not confirm whether the bank balances were real data from another person or hallucinations, and that unresolved question is the one Meta most needs to answer. Reader poll: Would you still use $META's Muse? Vote: Trust Muse less, Trust it the same, Delete the app.
Are you bullish or bearish on this story?
By The Numbers
FAQ
What is Meta's Muse?
Muse is Meta's personal AI agent, an app that answers questions, manages tasks and works across a user's phone and computer. It launched in September 2026 and has been downloaded more than 10 million times. Meta sees it as the centrepiece of its plan to make billions from AI.
What is end-to-end encryption?
End-to-end encryption is a way of scrambling messages so that only the sender and the recipient can read them — not even the company running the messaging app can see the contents. Signal is one of the best-known encrypted messaging apps, and it is built on the promise that nobody else can read your chats.
What is a hallucination in AI?
A hallucination is when an AI system confidently states something that is not true — inventing a fact, a number or a quote that sounds plausible but has no basis in reality. Meta says many of the apparent Muse mix-ups were hallucinations, while Reuters could not confirm whether the bank balances shown were real data from another person or invented.
👁
Source: Reuters