Judge refuses to dismiss DRAM price-fixing suit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron
A U.S. judge refused to dismiss a price-fixing lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron, ruling the complaint plausibly alleges a conspiracy. The case now heads to discovery.
📊 Scorecard: our Bearish call on $MU is scored from $778.31, the last close before it ran. Its first result comes after the next close.

The News
A federal judge has refused to throw out a price-fixing lawsuit against the world's three biggest makers of DRAM computer memory. U.S. District Judge Noel Wise, sitting in the Northern District of California, denied in full on November 14 the three companies' joint request to dismiss the case, ruling that the complaint plausibly alleges a conspiracy under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, America's main antitrust law.
The case, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, was filed on June 25, 2026 by 17 consumers and small businesses across five states. It alleges that Samsung, SK hynix and Micron — which together took more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025 — coordinated cuts to production of conventional DRAM from October 2022 to April 2023 and shifted factory capacity toward high-bandwidth memory, the expensive memory used in AI servers. The complaint alleges prices rose 697% over 18 months.
This is a pleading-stage ruling only, and that distinction matters. At this stage the judge takes the allegations as true and asks only whether they add up to a plausible claim — no liability has been found, and no wrongdoing has been proven. The case now moves toward discovery, the phase where both sides exchange documents and evidence. The companies' answers to the complaint are due December 7, 2026, and the first case-management conference is set for January 12, 2027. This is the November 14 ruling, a new event: an earlier post on November 14 covered the hearing, when no ruling had yet been issued.
The judge did not find price-fixing — she found the claim plausible enough to proceed. That is still bad news for the three memory giants.
Why It Matters
The ruling matters because of who is involved and how much of the market they control. Three companies taking more than 91% of global DRAM revenue means the memory market is one of the most concentrated in technology. If the plaintiffs can prove coordination, the damages could be large — and the case covers a period when memory prices were rising sharply, which is exactly when buyers feel squeezed.
It also matters because of the timing. Memory prices are already under pressure — NAND spot prices have fallen about 20% since late October, according to Bank of America — and a lawsuit that drags the three biggest makers into discovery adds legal risk at the worst moment. Even if the companies ultimately win, discovery is expensive, slow and public, and every filing will be read by investors.
But readers should keep the scale of the ruling in proportion. Denying a motion to dismiss is a low bar: it means the case can proceed, not that the plaintiffs will win. Many antitrust cases survive this stage and then settle or fail at trial. The ruling is real news, and it is negative for the three companies, but it is the start of a long legal process, not a verdict.
Analyst's Take
Our call is Bearish. A federal judge has now said the price-fixing claim is plausible enough to proceed to discovery, and the case targets the three companies that dominate the DRAM market. Legal overhang tends to weigh on shares for months, and this one arrives while memory prices are already softening.
The bearish case has limits. Nothing has been proven, the alleged conduct dates to 2022 and 2023, and the case may take years to resolve. The companies will argue that production cuts were a normal response to falling demand, not a conspiracy. If discovery produces little, the overhang could fade. But for now the direction of travel is against the defendants.
The next dates to watch are December 7, when the companies must answer the complaint, and January 12, when the court holds its first case-management conference. Until then, the ruling is a cloud over three of the most important stocks in the memory trade. Reader poll: Bullish or bearish on Micron? Vote: Bullish, Bearish, Mixed.
Are you bullish or bearish on this story?
By The Numbers
FAQ
What does it mean to deny a motion to dismiss?
It means the judge decided the complaint states a plausible legal claim, so the case can move forward. It is not a finding that the defendants did anything wrong.
What is the Sherman Act?
It is America's main antitrust law. Section 1 bans agreements between competitors that restrain trade, such as fixing prices or limiting production.
What happens next in the case?
The companies must file their answers by December 7, 2026, and the court holds its first case-management conference on January 12, 2027. Discovery — the exchange of documents and evidence — follows.
👁
Source: TrendForce