Morgan Stanley: Nvidia's Q3 numbers are priced in — Tuesday is all about guidance
The bank expects revenue of $108.1 billion and EPS of $2.47, but says the real question is whether management gives guidance at all in its first appearance since Huang stepped down.

The News
In a preview note published November 16–17, Morgan Stanley said the focus of Tuesday's report is not the quarter's numbers — which it calls fully priced in — but the first management appearance since Huang stepped down and next-year guidance that "might not even be provided." Morgan Stanley expects third-quarter revenue of $108.1 billion, slightly below the roughly $108.9 billion consensus, and earnings per share of $2.47, in line with consensus, with channel checks showing demand still outstripping supply even as some Southeast Asia projects slow.
The bigger divergence is 2028. Morgan Stanley forecasts fiscal 2028 revenue of $623 billion and earnings per share of $13.37, versus consensus of $694.8 billion and $15.75 — about $72 billion below consensus on revenue ($694.8B minus $623B) — with fiscal 2028 growth of 52% against the company's roughly 70% guidance. The bank keeps an Overweight rating and a $267 target, with a bull case of $336.
HSBC, by contrast, expects third-quarter revenue of $113 billion, above the $108 billion guide midpoint, and earnings per share of $2.55, about 3% above consensus — even though it downgraded the stock from Buy to Hold and cut its price target from $365 to $170. Morningstar's Brian Colello said, "We would be shocked if NVIDIA misses expectations or provides weak guidance," in the same report. Results are due Tuesday, November 17, at about 4:20 p.m. ET (1:20 p.m. PT), with the call at 5:00 p.m. ET.
The quarter is priced in. Tuesday is about whether Nvidia's new leadership will tell the market what comes next.
Why It Matters
Guidance matters more than the quarter because the stock price is a bet on the future. Nvidia's shares have already fallen roughly a third from their October peak, so the market has priced in a lot of bad news — but it has not priced in a number for 2028, because the company has not given one since the leadership change. Morgan Stanley's $623 billion forecast is a guess, and the consensus $694.8 billion is a different guess. Tuesday is when one of them gets tested.
The 52% versus 70% growth gap is the heart of it. The company's own guidance implied about 70% growth for fiscal 2028; Morgan Stanley expects 52%. That 18-point gap, on a revenue base of hundreds of billions, is worth tens of billions of dollars of sales — and it is exactly the kind of gap that decides whether Nvidia is a growth stock or a value stock.
The counterweight is demand. Morgan Stanley's own channel checks say demand still outstrips supply, and HSBC expects a beat on both revenue and earnings. If demand is genuinely stronger than supply, the guidance gap is a modelling argument, not a business problem. But a company that will not guide cannot prove that — which is why the call at 5:00 p.m. ET matters more than the release at 4:20.
Analyst's Take
Our call is Mixed. The quarter itself should be fine — Morgan Stanley and HSBC both expect revenue above the $108 billion guide midpoint ($108.1B and $113B respectively), channel checks say demand still outstrips supply, and Morningstar expects no miss. The stock's problem is not the past three months. It is the next three years, where Morgan Stanley sits about $72 billion below consensus on revenue.
That gap is the real debate, and Tuesday is the first chance to settle it. If management gives guidance — any guidance — the market gets a number to argue about instead of a vacuum. If it stays silent in its first appearance since Huang stepped down, the vacuum wins, and the stock will keep falling on other people's forecasts.
For readers, the practical point is to watch the call, not the headline numbers. Revenue of $108.1 billion versus $108.9 billion will not move the stock much. A guidance number — or the absence of one — will. Reader poll: Will Nvidia guide or stay silent? Vote: Bullish, Bearish, Mixed.
Are you bullish or bearish on this story?
By The Numbers
FAQ
What is EPS?
EPS stands for earnings per share — a company's profit divided by the number of shares. It is the standard way investors compare how much money a company made against what analysts expected.
What is guidance?
Guidance is a company's own forecast for its future sales and profits. Investors care about it more than last quarter's numbers, because the stock price reflects what happens next, not what already happened.
What does Overweight mean?
Overweight is a broker's recommendation that a stock should make up a bigger share of an investor's portfolio than its weight in the market index — in plain terms, a buy recommendation.
👁
Source: Longbridge